The double jeopardy KDF soldiers fac

Reading Time: 6 minutes
Kenya Defence Forces

Kenya Defence Forces soldiers strategise as they fight terror group Al-Shabaab in Somalia on February 11, 2017. The government said that on completion of their duty they are taken through post-deployment psychological debriefs. PHOTO | FILE | NATION MEDIA GROUP

In the US-backed war against the militant group Al-Shabaab in Somalia, Americans wage their battles mostly from the air, with unmanned drones.

On the ground, at sweltering checkpoints and in dusty trenches across Somalia’s southernmost states, soldiers from neighbouring Kenya do almost all the fighting.

Low-ranking Kenya Defence Forces (KDF) soldier Christopher Katitu was one of them. He had spent two years manning a mounted machine gun from a trench in Kismayo, a port city shattered by street-by-street skirmishes over territory.

And when Al-Shabaab killed almost 150 students atGarissa University just across the border, Mr Katitu was sent to the edges of the tense town to guard a highway checkpoint day and night.

A kind of pressure was building up in his brain, one he could not quite place. It was not just the war — money problems were intensifying at home, too, and his wife was angry with him. Through almost a decade in the army, he had never seen a counsellor.


On a short leave home from Garissa, Mr Katitu had a mental breakdown. But instead of being treated for post-traumatic stress disorder, he was jailed and court-martialled when he tried to rejoin his battalion.

Since Kenya joined the war in Somalia in 2011, the US has given the government more than $500 million (Sh50.5 billion) in security aid.

It comes with no stipulation that any of it is spent on mental healthcare for soldiers, but the US military trains KDF doctors in mental healthcare.

The KDF’s chief medical officer, Dr George Ng’ang’a, said, “if there’s one area where we’ve gone ahead, it is mental healthcare”.

But in interviews with former KDF doctors, mental health specialists and a dozen ex-KDF soldiers, a picture emerges of a system that has favoured discipline over mental healthcare in the cases of hundreds of soldiers.


Criticising the military in Kenya is taboo, and mental illness is rarely talked of both in the military and in society.

Eight years into Kenya’s military foray in Somalia, hundreds of Kenyan soldiers have been killed and dozens of Al-Shabaab raids occurred in Kenyan territory, some directed at KDF soldiers.

Kenya has around 4,000 troops in Somalia, which accounts for about one-fifth of the African Union contingent there.

The KDF says it conducts counselling services, but Dr Ng’ang’a said in an interview that the KDF has no records on mental illness, nor does it have a dedicated mental health facility.

He would not specify how many psychologists the KDF employs. The US Africa Command said it is “dedicated to supporting the development of capable, professional partner nation forces in Kenya”.

Mr Katitu said he was never offered an appointment with a counsellor and knew of no available options.

He was a year to qualifying for a pension. His father, an ex-soldier, had died, and Katitu’s pay was supporting a large extended family.


One day, his wife showed up at his barracks and said the money was not enough.

Mr Katitu was granted a week to go home and figure out his finances. “That’s when everything went black,” he said at his family’s farm some 160km east of Nairobi.

He knows about those weeks from what others told him… “that I was babbling about bombs and Somalis and so on. I guess when you leave your barracks that’s when everything hits you.”

Mr Katitu’s blackout turned into a nightmare, in a story other former soldiers echoed.

When he eventually reported for duty, he was stripped of his ID and phone, charged with desertion and locked in a cell for two years, awaiting a court-martial in which he was swiftly sentenced to six more months. For much of the time, his family did not know where he was.


Just before the trial, he met a psychologist — for the first time in his life — who told the court-martial that Mr Katitu exhibited signs of PTSD.

He was convicted of desertion anyway. “We are just sent here and there to fight without any mental preparation,” said Mr Katitu, now 32.

“I’ve never said no to an order. How can I be a deserter?” In June, a civilian judge sided with Mr Katitu in an appeal of the court-martial.

“Again, tragically, instead of (Katitu’s) medical problem being resolved by medical intervention, a decision was made to look at his absence from work as a criminal matter,” Judge Luka Kimaru wrote in his ruling, a non-binding decision that called for the KDF to reach a settlement with Mr Katitu. Almost a year later, the KDF has not reached out to him.

Major Lucy Mukuria, the KDF’s first psychologist who is now retired, said she has spoken with at least 800 soldiers who suffered from symptoms typical of PTSD, who were punished instead of treated.


Many who sought her help were demoted or discharged after commanders found out about their troubles.

“My reports were met by my superiors with disbelief,” she said. “Not once — not even once — was there follow-up. That crushed me. They are scared to admit there’s a problem, so they say you’re weak or incompetent and just try to get rid of you.”

Ms Mukuria, who served for 11 years before her own struggle with mental illness led her to quit, has been the most outspoken voice demanding a cultural shift within the KDF.

She devotes much of her time to organising events for former soldiers suffering from PTSD, where she shares her own experience with mental illness.

“I tell them that I’ve spent days lying in bed, thinking about the slumping bodies, covered in fluids and maggots in half-zipped body bags,” she said.

The worst memories come from the aftermath of an Al-Shabaab attack on a KDF outpost in El Adde, Somalia, three years ago that killed hundreds of soldiers.

“The bodies, they came in trucks, you know, trucks. I haven’t been able to smell since then; I’ve lost that entirely.”

Outside of get-togethers like Maj Mukuria’s, soldiers with mental illness who have been discharged have few affordable places to seek help.


Mr Iregi Mwenja runs the Psychiatric Disability Organisation of Kenya, which has treated some ex-soldiers close to its centre in the country’s Rift Valley, but for others, it’s just too far away.

“There’s no space for truth-telling on those bases,” he said. “The KDF treats soldiers like Western countries did during World War I.”

Mr Mwenja, Maj Mukuria and former soldiers said substance abuse and suicide were rife among those they treated or knew and described in painful detail how PTSD has ruined families and sparked violent outbursts.


Mr Michael “Bush” Busolo is caring for his cousin Mr Leonardo Shivachi these days. They grew up together and used to run with the same group of friends, but nowadays, Mr Shivachi is unpredictable, going missing for weeks at a time.

Drinking a bottle of cheap brandy on a recent night, Mr Shivachi said that he had never seen a psychologist and that he was dismissed by a commander who thought he was “acting funny.”

“The bitterness controls him sometimes,” said Mr Busolo, who lets Mr Shivachi live in a converted chicken coop in his yard in the mostly Somali neighbourhood of Eastleigh in Nairobi.

“That’s when he sees snipers in the buildings across the street. When he tells me he could drink our Somali neighbour’s blood. When he’ll sleep for two days straight without eating. No one around him understands. People tell him that if he was a real man, he’d still be in the army.”

Some, like Mr Katitu, are still holding on to the possibility that the KDF will compensate them or help them in some way.

Mr Isaac Heri, who was a lieutenant in Kenya’s Special Forces before he was dishonourably discharged for a violent outburst, said he did not want help; he just wanted the KDF to do better.

“I’m sitting here now, but my mind is in the bush, killing people,” he said.

“The KDF will tell you there’s a system of care, but I don’t know anything about it. There was no counselling offered, even at my level. All I’m asking is for some recognition that the way I feel is not my fault.”


But Dr Susan Gitau, who has been counselling KDF soldiers since 2012, warned against blaming the KDF saying PSTD is not a military only problem but a societal issue.

“Before Somalia, Kenyan soldiers had not been involved in a major war and there was no alarm about PTSD. Things are now different. There is a big number of soldiers who are returning home broken. Not even their families or the society know how to handle them,” Dr Gitau said.

“Society idolises soldiers and this makes the already bad situation worse.”

In October last year, KDF introduced a new office known as the Welfare Office to help with such cases.

“This office is tasked with provision of support to those living with disabilities incurred during service (serving and retired), families and dependents of deceased service personnel,” KDF said in a statement.

In a response to Parliament dated June 2014 to a query on how soldiers who suffer from PSTD are treated, former Defence Principal Secretary Monica Juma said that when troops return home on completion of their duty they are taken through post-deployment psychological debriefs.

“Cases of PSTD are treated. There is in place a psychology clinic at the Defence Forces Memorial Hospital in Nairobi which handles and manages PTSD cases,” Dr Juma told Parliament.

Additional reporting by Nyambega Gisessa

Source: Daily Nation By MAX BEARAK